<strong>The real competitive arena 2025 – Hungarian Universities</strong>

The real competitive arena 2025 – Hungarian Universities

Headline
The government, which has been in power for a decade and a half, has a peculiar relationship with higher education rankings. At the beginning of the period, the prime minister announced a program to get Hungarian universities into the top 200, which we immediately wrote about, saying that it was both impossible and unnecessary. In the mid-2000s, we saw signs of sobering up when the then minister responsible for higher education saw the best chances of reaching the top 200 in the subject-specific lists, which was realistic on the one hand and, with certain restrictions, could even be a meaningful goal on the other. However, in the last two to three years, the goal has become to reach the "top 100." Unfortunately, in light of this year's global rankings, this…
Read More
ERC: the long shadow of the Iron Curtain?

ERC: the long shadow of the Iron Curtain?

Headline
The key point is that we should not treat the ranking criteria as absolute. It is at least as important to consider where we stand in terms of cutting-edge research, and here we see a shocking decline, for example, in the success of Hungarian applications to the ERC, Europe's most important research funding program. Science policy must explain why, while Hungarian success was outstanding a decade and a half ago (we won as many ERC grants as all other Eastern European countries combined), in the last eight years we have won less than half that amount, i.e. between 2007 and 2016 (only Bulgaria and Serbia, with their minimal number of applications, showed such a decline). Meanwhile, there are a number of departments and research workshops at the international forefront, while…
Read More
Hungarian Ranking Positons – 2024

Hungarian Ranking Positons – 2024

Headline
The global rankings of Hungarian universities present a mixed picture: of the 11 institutions included in the list, three (ELTE, Szeged, Műegyetem) are included in all four of the authoritative overall lists. ELTE ranks highest in three of these, while Szeged ranks higher in the ARWU, clearly thanks to Katalin Karikó's 2023 Nobel Prize, which is an indicator factor in the case of the Shanghai rankings. Although QS does not evaluate Semmelweis University, it performed well in the other three rankings: it maintained its position in the ARWU, did not continue last year's decline in the THE, and remains the best Hungarian university in the 251-300 range, while it was the only Hungarian university to move up in the US News list, with the positions of the others deteriorating. THE's…
Read More
A Theoretical Ranking Analysis

A Theoretical Ranking Analysis

Headline
This research paper explores the intricate relationship between university rankings, mass democracy, and postmodernity, elucidating the societal shift in evaluating academic excellence. As higher education experiences mass democratization, rankings emerge as vital tools in the new information market, providing accessible metrics for an increasingly diverse audience. The concept of “medialization” underscores the impact of rankings on shaping public perception, as journalists, lacking deep understanding of academic intricacies, turn to rankings for clarity. Reactivity within universities to achieve higher ranking placements underscores the internal influence of external media-driven evaluations. The paper argues that postmodern relativism challenges traditional meritocracy, disrupting the established communicative status of universities. Amidst ongoing debates about the legitimacy of rankings, the research recommends embracing a communicative meritocracy as a strategic response, emphasizing the importance of universities actively shaping…
Read More
COARA and Rankings

COARA and Rankings

Headline
Launched in January 2022 as a co-creation exercise, the process of drafting an agreement for reforming research assessment has reached an important milestone. On 8 July, the final version of the agreement was presented at a Stakeholder Assembly bringing together the 350+ organisations from 40+ countries having expressed interest in being involved in the process. Today, the final Agreement is made public with this news. Organisations involved include public and private research funders, universities, research centres, institutes and infrastructures, associations (and alliances thereof), national and regional authorities, accreditation and evaluation agencies, learned societies and associations of researchers, and other relevant organisations. They represent a broad diversity of views and perspectives. They have provided feedback to the evolving drafts of the agreement, as prepared by a team composed of representatives from the European University Association…
Read More
Rankings: changes ante portas?

Rankings: changes ante portas?

Global Ranking Monitor, Headline
At the end of April, the International Ranking Expert Group (IREG), the only independent international ranking organisation, held its annual conference in Tashkent. Such IREG events are of particular importance because they bring together global ranking compilers, ranking experts and representatives of many universities and government agencies. This year's conference was also special in that it took place in a region relatively distant from the centre of higher education - and demonstrated the openness and connectivity of Central Asian universities through excellent organisation and very warm hospitality. In terms of content, a significant development was that almost all the presentations marked a change in the world of global rankings. As they put it, nothing will ever be the same in the wake of geopolitical and academic changes. The directions of…
Read More
University Rankings and the ChatGPT – Two Answers

University Rankings and the ChatGPT – Two Answers

Headline, Studies
One of the two answers was written by Dr. György Fábri PhD, the editor-in-chief of our site, and the other by chatGPT. How can you decide which one is which?? And which do you agree with? Can replace ChatGPT the university rankings? No, chatbots like ChatGPT cannot replace university rankings. University rankings are usually compiled by independent organizations using various criteria such as academic reputation, research output, student satisfaction, and employability of graduates. They are a form of evaluation and comparison of universities based on a set of specific criteria. On the other hand, ChatGPT is an AI-powered language model that can generate human-like text based on the input it receives. It can answer questions and provide information, but it does not have the capability to evaluate or rank universities.…
Read More